Fraud Blocker

The Atlantic Sandwich Shop is closed for the 2026 season. Thank you so much for your support, and we look forward to seeing you again in 2027!

A hand holds a deli-style sandwich with veggies on a seaside beach, with people and ocean blurred in the background.
A “The Atlantic” sandwich menu and green-and-white wrapped sandwiches sit on a wooden board beside blue-and-white striped cloth.

    Fresh, Coastal Flavors To Go

    Atlantic Sandwich Shop

    Introducing the Atlantic Sandwich Shop, your new destination for handcrafted sandwiches, fresh ingredients, and easy coastal dining at The Atlantic Inn. Whether you're heading to the beach, enjoying a day on the island, or simply craving a delicious lunch, our thoughtfully crafted menu is made for easy takeout and relaxed weekend dining.

    Hours of Operation

    Closed for the 2026 season